Ask a small hotel or short-stay operator what their biggest cost is and you will usually hear staff, or cleaning, or the mortgage. Almost nobody says distribution. Yet for a property that takes most of its business through the big online travel agents, commission is frequently the second-largest line item in the business — and unlike wages or laundry, it is one you can move without anyone doing more work.
The reason it hides so well is that it never arrives as a bill. It is deducted before the money reaches you, so it shows up as a slightly smaller number rather than an expense you have to approve. Costs you never approve are costs you never question.
Work out your real commission rate
Start with the actual figure rather than the headline one. Booking.com commission commonly sits around 15% and rises with visibility programmes; Expedia's is typically higher; Airbnb splits its fee between host and guest, or charges the host alone at a higher rate. The published percentages are the floor, not the number you are paying.
The number that matters is your blended rate across everything:
Total commission paid over the last 12 months ÷ total revenue over the last 12 months.
Take the whole year, not a good month. Include every channel. If you are on a visibility or preferred-partner programme, that surcharge belongs in the numerator too. Most operators who do this arithmetic honestly for the first time find a number several points above what they would have guessed.
Then convert it into something you can feel. A property turning over $300,000 a year at a blended 17% is paying about $51,000 in commission. That is a full-time salary. It is a refurbishment. Expressed as a percentage it sounds like a cost of doing business; expressed as a salary it sounds like a decision.
Why "just leave the OTAs" is the wrong conclusion
It is worth saying plainly, because the direct-booking conversation attracts a lot of absolutism: the OTAs earn a good part of what they take. They provide genuine demand you would not otherwise reach, they handle discovery for travellers who have never heard of you, and for a new or seasonal property they can be the difference between running at 40% occupancy and 75%. Commission on a booking you would never have received is not a loss.
The goal is not zero OTA business. The goal is to stop paying full commission on the bookings you have already earned — the guest who found you on Booking.com in March, loved it, and books through Booking.com again in September. That second booking cost the OTA nothing to generate and cost you the same 15–20% as the first. That is the money worth chasing, and it is the easiest to win, because the guest already wants to come back.
The moves that actually shift the mix
Most direct-booking advice is either too vague to act on or assumes a marketing budget you do not have. These are the ones that pay for themselves quickly.
Make sure you can actually be booked directly. This sounds too obvious to state, but a large share of small operators still have a website that lists rooms and then asks people to email. Every step between "I want this" and "it's confirmed" loses a meaningful fraction of people. If a guest has to wait until tomorrow morning for a reply, they will have booked elsewhere by then — usually on the OTA, where the button worked. Live availability and real prices, on your own domain, is the entire game.
Price parity is about the total, not the nightly rate. Most OTA contracts restrict undercutting the room rate, and breaching that is a bad idea. But rate parity clauses generally do not cover what you include. Late checkout, a welcome drink, parking, a room upgrade when available, breakfast — none of these are the nightly rate, and all of them make the direct option obviously better value at the same price. Compete on the package.
Capture the guest while they are standing in front of you. The single highest-return direct-booking activity is the thirty seconds at check-out where someone who has just had a good stay is told, in person, that booking direct next time gets them the better deal, with a card in their hand that says how. It costs nothing and it converts far better than any advertising you could buy with the same effort.
Own the email address. OTAs increasingly mask guest contact details, so collect it yourself at check-in as part of the registration you are doing anyway, with a clear opt-in. A list of past guests who enjoyed their stay is the most valuable marketing asset a small property can own, and it is the one asset the OTAs cannot take back from you when they change their terms.
Be findable for your own name. A surprising number of guests search the property by name, land on an OTA page ranking above the property's own site, and book there. If your own site does not rank first for your own name, you are paying commission for traffic that was explicitly looking for you. That is worth an afternoon's attention.
Keep the calendars honest
There is a reason many operators stay over-dependent on one channel: managing several manually is genuinely awful. Two systems means double entry; double entry means drift; drift means a double booking, and one double booking on a peak weekend is expensive enough — in refunds, in a bad review, in the hour you spend apologising — to wipe out a season's commission savings.
This is the part where the tooling actually matters. Rooms, rates and availability should sync in both directions across every channel you sell on, including your own website, from one place. Once that is true, adding a channel is a decision about demand rather than a decision about how much administration you can absorb. Until it is true, "reduce OTA dependency" is advice you cannot safely act on.
A reasonable target
Do not aim to flip the mix overnight; aim to move it. An operator who takes their direct share from 10% to 30% over a year, on that same $300,000 turnover, keeps roughly $10,000 that used to leave the business — without raising a rate, adding a room, or working a longer day.
Start by calculating your blended rate. The number itself tends to do most of the persuading.
IPropertyPro runs sales, lettings and short-stay from one system. Start free — no card needed.